In the early 2000s, a young music lover from a small town, with limited access and an insatiable craving for songs, turned to the wild world of online downloading. In I Used to Steal Music, they reflect on this era with a mix of nostalgia, embarrassment, and an earnest desire to give back to the artists whose music shaped their life. Now an adult, they’ve decided to do something unconventional: reach out to these artists one by one with a personal check for $50 and a heartfelt letter of apology.

Each episode follows their journey as they mail these letters, sharing deep admiration for the artist’s craft, expressing thanks for the memories their music created, and asking for nothing in return. Each letter also includes an open invitation for the artist to come on the show to discuss their thoughts on music, art, and how the industry has transformed over the decades. Through these conversations, the podcast explores how artists’ perspectives have evolved, the impact of streaming, and what’s next for the music industry.

With a mix of humor, sincerity, and a true love of music, I Used to Steal Music is a touching and innocent exploration of the ways art impacts us, the shifting landscape of music, and what it means to finally give back—even if it’s just a small gesture.